Conversation
Summary of ChangesHello, I'm Gemini Code Assist1! I'm currently reviewing this pull request and will post my feedback shortly. In the meantime, here's a summary to help you and other reviewers quickly get up to speed! This pull request focuses on enhancing the NAPI resolver's test coverage and modernizing its testing infrastructure. It involves a complete migration of the resolver's test suite from Highlights
🧠 New Feature in Public Preview: You can now enable Memory to help Gemini Code Assist learn from your team's feedback. This makes future code reviews more consistent and personalized to your project's style. Click here to enable Memory in your admin console. Using Gemini Code AssistThe full guide for Gemini Code Assist can be found on our documentation page, here are some quick tips. Invoking Gemini You can request assistance from Gemini at any point by creating a comment using either
Customization To customize Gemini Code Assist for GitHub experience, repository maintainers can create a configuration file and/or provide a custom code review style guide (such as PEP-8 for Python) by creating and adding files to a Limitations & Feedback Gemini Code Assist may make mistakes. Please leave feedback on any instances where its feedback is incorrect or counter productive. You can react with 👍 and 👎 on @gemini-code-assist comments. If you're interested in giving your feedback about your experience with Gemini Code Assist for GitHub and other Google products, sign up here. Footnotes
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Code Review
This pull request successfully migrates the test suite from ava to rstest and synchronizes a significant number of test cases from enhanced-resolve. The strategy of marking failing or unsupported tests as skipped with clear explanations is an excellent way to manage and track future work. The updates to package.json and the new rstest configuration files are appropriate for this migration. I have one suggestion to enhance the robustness of one of the new configuration files.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Pull request overview
Updates the resolver’s test suite by syncing a large set of enhanced-resolve compatibility fixtures/cases and migrating the JavaScript test runner to @rstest/core, while keeping currently failing cases marked as skipped for follow-up.
Changes:
- Replace AVA/node:test usage with
@rstest/coreand addrstestconfig files + updatedpackage.jsonscripts. - Add/port many
enhanced-resolvecompatibility tests intonapi/tests/**andnapi/__test__/**. - Add new
enhanced-resolvefixture content (tsconfig-paths, exports/imports cases, unsafe-cache-normalization, etc.) and minor docs/formatting updates.
Reviewed changes
Copilot reviewed 87 out of 89 changed files in this pull request and generated 4 comments.
Show a summary per file
| File | Description |
|---|---|
| rstest.config.resolver.mjs | Adds rstest config for napi/__test__ suite (incl. externals for native bindings/WASI). |
| rstest.config.mjs | Adds rstest config for napi/tests enhanced-resolve-compatible suite (externals for native binding). |
| pnpm-lock.yaml | Updates lockfile to include rstest and related dependency graph changes. |
| package.json | Switches test scripts to rstest and updates devDependencies (removes AVA, adds @rstest/core). |
| napi/tests/tsconfig-paths.test.mjs | Adds enhanced-resolve tsconfig-paths compatibility tests (incl. skipped known gaps). |
| napi/tests/scoped-packages.test.mjs | Adds scoped package resolution tests. |
| napi/tests/roots.test.mjs | Adds tests for roots option behavior. |
| napi/tests/restrictions.test.mjs | Adds tests for restrictions behavior (incl. skipped known gap). |
| napi/tests/resolve.test.mjs | Adds general resolve behavior tests (ported cases). |
| napi/tests/options.test.mjs | Migrates options tests to rstest/expect assertions. |
| napi/tests/incorrect-description-file.test.mjs | Adds tests for incorrect package.json description file behavior. |
| napi/tests/importsField.test.mjs | Adds imports field resolution tests (incl. skipped known gaps). |
| napi/tests/extensions.test.mjs | Adds extension resolution ordering/edge case tests. |
| napi/tests/extension-alias.test.mjs | Adds extensionAlias behavior tests. |
| napi/tests/exportsField.test.mjs | Adds extensive exports field compatibility tests (with documented skips). |
| napi/tests/browserField.test.mjs | Adds browser field aliasing behavior tests. |
| napi/test/resolver.test.mjs | Replaces AVA resolver suite with rstest-based suite (incl. parameterized cases + WASI conditional). |
| napi/test/resolver.spec.mjs | Removes old AVA-based resolver test file. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/unsafe-cache-normalization/src/shared/index.js | Adds unsafe-cache-normalization fixture module. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/unsafe-cache-normalization/src/components/index.js | Fixture file for unsafe-cache-normalization scenario. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/unsafe-cache-normalization/src/b/index.js | Adds unsafe-cache-normalization fixture module. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/unsafe-cache-normalization/src/a/b/index.js | Adds unsafe-cache-normalization nested fixture module. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/unsafe-cache-normalization/packages/nested/src/index.js | Adds nested package fixture entry. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/unsafe-cache-normalization/packages/nested/package.json | Adds nested package fixture manifest. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/unsafe-cache-normalization/package.json | Adds root fixture manifest. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/references-project/tsconfig.json | Adds project-references fixture tsconfig. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/references-project/src/main.ts | Adds project-references fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/references-project/packages/utils/tsconfig.json | Adds utils referenced-project tsconfig fixture. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/references-project/packages/utils/src/core/date.ts | Adds utils referenced-project fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/references-project/packages/shared/tsconfig.json | Adds shared referenced-project tsconfig fixture. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/references-project/packages/shared/src/utils/helper.ts | Adds shared referenced-project fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/references-project/packages/shared/src/index.ts | Adds shared referenced-project fixture entry. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/references-project/packages/shared/src/components/Input.ts | Adds shared referenced-project component fixture. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/references-project/packages/shared/index.ts | Adds shared package root fixture entry. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/references-project/packages/app/tsconfig.json | Adds app referenced-project tsconfig fixture. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/references-project/packages/app/src/index.ts | Adds app referenced-project fixture entry. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/references-project/packages/app/src/components/Button.ts | Adds app referenced-project component fixture. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/malformed-json/tsconfig.json | Adds malformed-json fixture for error handling. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/jsonc-comments/tsconfig.json | Adds JSONC-with-comments tsconfig fixture. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/jsonc-comments/src/mapped/foo/index.ts | Adds JSONC fixture mapped source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/jsonc-comments/src/mapped/bar/index.ts | Adds JSONC fixture mapped source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/jsonc-comments/src/components/button.ts | Adds JSONC fixture component source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-pkg-entry/tsconfig.json | Adds tsconfig extends-package-entry fixture. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-npm/tsconfig.json | Adds tsconfig extends-from-npm fixture. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-npm/src/utils/date.ts | Adds extends-npm fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-npm/src/index.ts | Adds extends-npm fixture entry. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-npm/src/components/button.ts | Adds extends-npm fixture component. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-deep-baseurl/tsconfig-base/tsconfig.json | Adds deep-extends baseUrl fixture base config. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-deep-baseurl/tsconfig-base/src/utils/format.ts | Adds deep-extends fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-deep-baseurl/packages/lib/tsconfig.json | Adds deep-extends fixture intermediate tsconfig. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-deep-baseurl/packages/app/tsconfig.json | Adds deep-extends fixture app tsconfig. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-circular/b/tsconfig.json | Adds circular-extends fixture tsconfig (b). |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-circular/b/src/util/bar.ts | Adds circular-extends fixture source (b). |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-circular/a/tsconfig.json | Adds circular-extends fixture tsconfig (a). |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-circular/a/src/lib/foo.ts | Adds circular-extends fixture source (a). |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-base/tsconfig.json | Adds base-extends fixture tsconfig. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-base/src/utils/date.ts | Adds base-extends fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-base/src/index.ts | Adds base-extends fixture entry. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-base/src/components/button.ts | Adds base-extends fixture component. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/tsconfig.json | Adds base tsconfig-paths fixture config with mappings. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/utils/date.ts | Adds base tsconfig-paths fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/refs/index.ts | Adds base tsconfig-paths refs fixture module. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/mapped/star/star-bar/index.ts | Adds base tsconfig-paths star mapping fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/mapped/star/no-main-field-package/package.json | Adds no-main-field package fixture manifest. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/mapped/star/no-main-field-package/index.ts | Adds no-main-field package fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/mapped/star/main-field-package/package.json | Adds main-field package fixture manifest. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/mapped/star/main-field-package/node.ts | Adds main-field package fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/mapped/star/browser-field-package/package.json | Adds browser-field package fixture manifest. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/mapped/star/browser-field-package/node.ts | Adds browser-field package fixture node entry. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/mapped/star/browser-field-package/browser.ts | Adds browser-field package fixture browser entry. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/mapped/longest/two.ts | Adds longest-prefix fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/mapped/longest/three.ts | Adds longest-prefix fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/mapped/longest/one.ts | Adds longest-prefix fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/mapped/foo/index.ts | Adds mapped foo fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/mapped/bar/file1.ts | Adds mapped bar/* fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/index.ts | Adds base fixture entry that exercises path mappings. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/components/new-file.ts | Adds remap target fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/base/src/components/button.ts | Adds component fixture source. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/imports-slash-pattern/src/utils.js | Adds imports slash-pattern fixture module. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/imports-slash-pattern/src/nested/deep.js | Adds nested imports slash-pattern fixture module. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/imports-slash-pattern/package.json | Adds imports slash-pattern fixture manifest. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/imports-field-different/package.json | Adds “imports-field-different” fixture manifest. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/imports-field-different/a.js | Adds imports-field-different fixture module. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/imports-field-chain/the.js | Adds imports-field-chain fixture module. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/imports-field-chain/package.json | Adds imports-field-chain fixture manifest. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/exports-field-invalid-package-target/package.json | Adds invalid exports target fixture manifest. |
| fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/exports-field-invalid-package-target/a.js | Adds invalid exports target fixture module. |
| README.md | Adjusts the options table formatting in documentation. |
| .prettierignore | Ignores the intentionally malformed tsconfig fixture for formatting. |
Files not reviewed (1)
- pnpm-lock.yaml: Language not supported
💡 Add Copilot custom instructions for smarter, more guided reviews. Learn how to get started.
| "test": "npm run test:resolver && npm run test:enhanced-resolve-compatible", | ||
| "test:resolver": "rstest run -c rstest.config.resolver.mjs", | ||
| "test:enhanced-resolve-compatible": "rstest run -c rstest.config.mjs", |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The test script shells out to npm run ... even though the repo is pinned to pnpm (and CI uses pnpm test). Using pnpm run test:resolver / pnpm run test:enhanced-resolve-compatible avoids mixing package managers and tends to behave more consistently across environments.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Codex Review
Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.
Reviewed commit: c5a9105916
ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub
Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you
- Open a pull request for review
- Mark a draft as ready
- Comment "@codex review".
If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.
Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".
fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-npm/tsconfig.json
Show resolved
Hide resolved
fixtures/enhanced_resolve/test/fixtures/tsconfig-paths/extends-pkg-entry/tsconfig.json
Show resolved
Hide resolved
Co-authored-by: gemini-code-assist[bot] <176961590+gemini-code-assist[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
Sync enhanced-resolve test cases
Keep failed test cases as skipped, for later follow-up.
Migrate to rstest